Middletown, NJ Listings Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining Half Moon $ 132 reviews Bars, Seafood (732) 787-3560 2 Beachway AveKeansburg, NJ 07734 The Atlantic House $ 106 reviews Bars, Diners, Fish & Chips (848) 300-2408 67 1st AveAtlantic Highlands, NJ 07716 Salt Creek Grille $$ 845 reviews New American, Seafood, Steakhouses (732) 933-9272 4 Bingham AveRumson, NJ 07760 Mule Barn Tavern $$ 118 reviews Pizza, Burgers, Chicken Wings (732) 233-9277 36 Kearney RdHighlands, NJ 07732 Gabriella's Italian Steakhouse $$$ 469 reviews Italian, Steakhouses (732) 456-6699 447 State Rte 35Red Bank, NJ 07701 Christines Italian $$$ 237 reviews Italian, Venues & Event Spaces, Seafood (732) 872-4790 42 1st AveAtlantic Highlands, NJ 07716 Barnacle Bill's $$ 433 reviews Bars, New American, Burgers (732) 747-8396 1 1st StRumson, NJ 07760 Hudson Cafe $$ 89 reviews Breakfast & Brunch (732) 872-2300 25 1st AveAtlantic Highlands, NJ 07716 Victory Park Tavern $ 55 reviews Venues & Event Spaces, American (732) 842-6205 21 W River RdRumson, NJ 07760 Sirens Seafood $ 9 reviews Seafood, Sandwiches (848) 300-2099 910 State Rte 36Middletown Township, NJ 07737 Zoe's Emilio's Kitchen $ 70 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Coffee & Tea, Mexican (732) 204-7311 77 Center AveAtlantic Highlands, NJ 07716 Pueblo Magico $$ 114 reviews Mexican, Desserts, Breakfast & Brunch (732) 201-0251 80 Leonardville RdBelford, NJ 07718 Saltwater Bar and Kitchen by Big Mike $ 43 reviews Bars, New American, Seafood (732) 444-2055 128 Bay AveHighlands, NJ 07732 Nicholas Barrel & Roost $$ 496 reviews Bars, American, Pizza (732) 345-9977 160 NJ-35Red Bank, NJ 07701 Sissy's At the Harbor $ 91 reviews American (732) 291-2218 8 Simon Lake DrAtlantic Highlands, NJ 07716 On The Deck Restaurant and Bar $$ 265 reviews Seafood, Bars, American (732) 872-1424 10 Simon Lake DrAtlantic Highlands, NJ 07716 The Seafarer Bar $ 57 reviews American 1 Atlantic StHighlands, NJ 07732 River Pointe Inn $ 24 reviews American, French, Cocktail Bars (732) 530-6590 132 E River RdRumson, NJ 07760 Gaslight $$ 143 reviews Gastropubs (732) 291-8333 33 1st AveAtlantic Highlands, NJ 07716 Belford Bistro $$$ 136 reviews New American (732) 495-8151 870 Main StBelford, NJ 07718 2nd Jetty Seafood $$ 261 reviews Seafood (732) 224-8700 140 Ocean AveSea Bright, NJ 07760 Birravino $$$ 689 reviews Italian, Wine Bars (732) 842-5990 183 Riverside AveRed Bank, NJ 07701 Monty’s BBQ $ 39 reviews Barbeque, Smokehouse (732) 204-2437 71 First AveAtlantic Highlands, NJ 07716 Proving Ground Waterfront Dining $$ 386 reviews Tiki Bars, Seafood, Burgers (732) 872-2266 56 Shrewsbury AveHighlands, NJ 07732 One Willow $$$ 194 reviews Seafood, Live/Raw Food (732) 730-7770 1 Willow StHighlands, NJ 07732